Summaries
Exploring the impact of using collaborative planning and pupil voice in the development of a scheme of work.
- Qualitative
- Teacher
- Secondary
- Classroom integration
- Education and Language
- Digital Learning
- Perspectives
The project looks at the collaborative planning and evaluation of a journalistic writing unit for secondary English student where a group were working towards a shared goal, it will be something all teachers will be able to utilise and hopefully it will have future impacts for teaching and learning going forward. Additionally, I am hoping it solves the issue of teachers being unclear or confused on what is expected of them when a completely new scheme of work is expected to be delivered by them when they have had no input in the planning. My research questions were developed after the completion of my literature review as a lot of my academic research pointed to the fact that using pupil voice aids student performance and engagement. Does collaborative planning lead to a more successful implementation of a scheme of work? What are the recommendations with regards to using collaboration to improve curriculum planning in schools? Does involving pupil voice in a scheme of work lead to higher engagement and academic achievement? A summary of the findings is as follows: Collaborative planning is integral to ensuring consistency across the teaching of a scheme of work. All future schemes of work should involve an initial meeting with all teachers to outline what should be included and what needs to be assessed. Planning of a scheme of work should fall on one teacher to ensure fluidity and consistency with the scheme and subsequent PowerPoint presentation. The teacher who conducted the planning must be given time during departmental meetings, prior to the scheme being launched, to discuss the scheme, make any final adjustments and clear any misconceptions from other teachers. Following the teaching of a scheme all teachers must provide honest feedback and recommendations for improvements.
Collaborative planning is integral to ensuring consistency across the teaching of a scheme of work. All future schemes of work should involve an initial meeting with all teachers to outline what should be included and what needs to be assessed. Planning of a scheme of work should fall on one teacher to ensure fluidity and consistency with the scheme and subsequent PowerPoint presentation. The teacher who conducted the planning must be given time during departmental meetings, prior to the scheme being launched, to discuss the scheme, make any final adjustments and clear any misconceptions from other teachers. Following the teaching of a scheme all teachers must provide honest feedback and recommendations for improvements.
Exploring the Influence of Setting Type, Qualifications and Experience on Early Years Practitioners’ Responses to Children’s Negative Emotions
- Learning environment
- Teacher
- Education and Language
- Early years
- Perspectives
Children develop a vital set of emotional competencies during their infant years, such as the ability to recognise and understand different emotions and the ability to respond appropriately to different emotions (often referred to as ‘emotional regulation’). These competencies lay the foundation for a range of important outcomes, such as academic achievement (Blankson et al., 2017; Ursache et al., 2020), social relationships (Denham et al., 2015) and pro-social behaviours (Fatahi et al., 2023; Ornaghi et al., 2017). It is therefore essential to understand what influences the successful development of these emotional skills in children, in order to optimise their later life outcomes. Adults play an important part in shaping a child’s emotional competencies through the way that they react to children, particularly during situations when the child is experiencing a negative emotion, e.g. fear, anger and sadness (Davidov & Grusec, 2006). Studies have shown that when adults respond to these situations in a positive way (e.g. accepting, coaching, problem-solving approaches) it facilitates children’s emotional competencies, but that when they respond to situations in a negative way (e.g. dismissive, punitive, critical approaches), it hinders their development (Denham et al., 2000; Eisenberg et al., 1996; Scrimgeour et al., 2016). Whilst parents have an important role in developing their child’s emotional skills by responding to them supportively, so too do staff within the child’s educational/care setting. Existing evidence from the USA has shown that experience and qualification level could influence how practitioners respond to children’s negative emotions (Denham et al., 2017). However, given the international differences in early years education systems, it is important that this is explored within the context of English settings. Therefore, this study investigated the factors which could influence how pre-school practitioners respond to children’s negative emotions, by exploring the role of: setting type (private/voluntary or school-based), qualification status and experience level. An online survey was completed by 109 pre-school practitioners working in different setting types across England. The sample represented a range of experience and qualification levels, although it was more skewed towards highly experienced, degree-qualified practitioners. The online survey included a series of hypothetical scenarios of a child experiencing a negative emotion that are likely to be encountered in a pre-school environment, such as losing their favourite toy and becoming upset. For each scenario, participants were provided with six statements describing different ways of reacting, and were asked to rate their likelihood of reacting to the given scenario in that way. These reaction statements could be grouped into supportive and non-supportive categories. Analyses were carried out to explore how different groups of practitioners, according to setting type, qualification and experience, responded to the different scenarios. The findings show that qualification and experience levels have a combined effect on likelihood to respond to situations, and that less experienced practitioners without a degree are more likely to react in a non-supportive way than those with a degree. The type of setting that practitioners work in does not appear to influence how they respond to children’s negative emotions. However, this warrants further research as the sample in this study was not as representative for the private/voluntary sector workforce as it was for the school-based workforce. Studies have also demonstrated that stress and emotional wellbeing can negatively influence how an adult responds to children using supportive strategies (Buettner et al., 2016). This is an important avenue for future research, in order to identify if there are differences in stress and emotional wellbeing according to setting type, experience and qualification level, and the resulting impact of this on practitioners’ ability to respond to children in a supportive way.
Gaining a better understanding of the factors which influence how an adult responds to a child’s negative emotions is crucial in being able to direct support appropriately, to ensure that children have optimal opportunities to develop their emotional competencies. This exploratory study is the first of its kind in England and offers a valuable insight into the combined role of experience and qualification in determining how practitioners are likely to respond to children’s negative emotional expressions. The findings of this research would be useful for pre-school leaders who are responsible for the professional development of staff within their setting. It is important that all staff, regardless of experience and qualification level, are equipped with the skills to use supportive strategies to develop children’s emotional competencies. This research would help to give pre-school leaders a better awareness of potential training needs that early-career professionals without a degree might have. The research findings may also benefit course leaders and tutors working in college-based settings that offer non-degree training routes into Early Years careers (e.g. apprenticeships, NVQ diplomas). It is essential that training programmes sufficiently prepare practitioners to be able to supportively develop children’s emotional competencies. Therefore, course leaders and tutors should consider whether their course content and training support includes this extensively enough within the programme of study.
Exploring the perspectives of teachers, through a risk and resilience lens, on the educational achievement of Pupil Premium students in a mainstream secondary school
- Secondary
- Adolescents
- Mainstream
- Education and Language
- Perspectives
This research aimed to understand barriers faced by disadvantaged students (as identified by the PP criteria) from the perspectives of secondary school teachers. There has been a long-standing attainment gap between disadvantaged students and those from higher SES backgrounds. The research was viewed through several theoretical perspectives, which in combination provided a more holistic understanding of the PP situation. The predominant psychological framework was that of Risk and Resilience, which identifies risk (difficulties) and protective (resilience) factors. In addition, this research considered the particular issues inherent in the post-COVID cost-of-living crisis period. The research topic, time period and use of several analysis frameworks is not prevalent in the wider research literature. The study took place in a secondary school in Oldham, which has areas of deprivation and thus a high proportion of PP students. Eight teacher-participants were selected for the study via purposive convenience sampling (i.e. those teachers replying first being selected). One-to-one, audio-recorded semi-structured interviews (i.e. open-ended questions with opportunities for discussion) were the chosen method of data gathering. This qualitative approach aimed to gather in-depth (‘rich’) viewpoints, as opposed to quantitative (statistical) generalisable data. The interview transcripts were explored via an inductive thematic analysis (identifying, themes and patterns within the data); three themes then emerged: Parent and school partnership; Contextual factors affecting education; Pedagogical (teaching methods) responses and approaches of teachers. Viewing the data through the Risk and Resilience framework, the following risk and protective factors were identified and were found to be consistent with existing literature. Those factors, which are external influences include: cultural capital (defined as the knowledge, skills and cultural experiences required to progress in an educational context) of PP students being insufficiently rich enough for the National Curriculum and cultural capital which is different from the requirements of the National Curriculum. These factors stem from the habitus (deeply ingrained set of attitudes and dispositions) that are the foundations of the home lives of many PP students. These findings are as per the seminal work of Bourdieu’s theory of social practice. The resulting consequences are that much defined National Curriculum school work has little connection or appeal to PP students and the psychological response is that many PP students have reduced motivation, which can then lead them being open to resistant-behaviour. In addition, the post-COVID cost-of-living crisis has created significant financial burdens and time constraints, leading to reduced support from parents. Another identified external risk factor, but one currently not present within existing literature to any great extent, is the: further marginalisation of students subject to the effects of a digital divide due to teachers relying on greater IT utilisation to reduce teaching workload. This has arisen from improved IT self-efficacy in the teaching profession during COVID-19. Factors that the research identified that support academic attainment and thus build resilience in PP students are external protective factors of: caring and strong support networks (between teachers/students, teachers/parents) and include school connectedness; a positive classroom emotional-climate; developing educational skills in parents (e.g. developing parents’ understanding of university financing). These have been implemented via structures and policies that include: QFT and Breakfast Clubs. These also aid in providing cost-of-living support. All these policies aim to increase the internal resilience in students. The findings are consistent with wider literature. For future studies, it is recommended that a longitudinal study be conducted of the long-term effects of COVID-19 and the subsequent cost-of-living crisis on the educational attainment of PP students.
The research is particularly useful for the target-school, which can benefit from obtaining an enhanced overview of the understanding of their staff on the PP situation, and the views of teachers on the PP strategies that are currently in place. This could help senior leaders to allocate PP monies more effectively. Further to this, the research could be especially valuable for secondary school teachers across the Oldham local authority, and also to those who teach in similar demographics but in different locations throughout England. Such schools may have similar risk factors and all schools would benefit from the implementation of the protective (resilience) factors. Nevertheless, representation of geographically diverse areas in the study is limited and thus the findings may not be applicable to other locations in England. Therefore, applicability of the study needs to be considered carefully. Issues arising concerning the marginalisation of disadvantaged students will need to be considered from a wider educational and curricula context. Educational policies and curriculum content may need to be altered to align more with the cultural capital of PP students. However, this may give rise to the debate on whether the curriculum may become at risk of being less challenging. As well as this, other educational establishments can benefit from the research as they can gain an insight into other PP strategies and structures to implement protective factors. Furthermore, the teaching profession can utilise the findings of this dissertation-research to support in the structuring of their own interventions and support strategies, leading to optimisation of the distribution of PP monies, and ultimately resulting in a narrowing of the PP educational attainment gap. The findings can also support PP parents in understanding how they may be impacting on their child's academic resilience, and consequently aid parents to become better equipped in supporting their child’s education and well-being, and advocating for resources and support to enable their child to prosper.
Exploring the Relationship between Indonesian English Teachers’ Emotion Regulation and Psychological Well-Being at Work with Their Work Engagement
- Teacher
- Survey
- Quantitative
- Wellbeing
- Emotion
- Education and Language
- Perspectives
Research has demonstrated that work engagement among English teachers will have several positive outcomes, such as higher job satisfaction and increased participation in non-core roles. In Indonesia, teaching English also has its challenges, including frequent changes in curriculum as well as low status and wages. Due to these various challenges, Indonesian English teachers’ work engagement remains a major challenge. Two factors that are linked to work engagement include emotion regulation and psychological well-being at work. Emotion regulation consists of two aspects, including reappraisal and suppression. Psychological well-being at work has five domains, such as the desire for involvement at work, interpersonal fit at work, feeling of competency at work, thriving at work, and perceived recognition at work. This study aimed to examine the predictive relationship between emotion regulation and psychological well-being at work with work engagement. Specifically, reappraisal and thriving at work were looked at in more depth as they were the most significant predictors of variance in work engagement. The target population was English teachers in Indonesia. The survey was spread out through WhatsApp and e-mail, and teachers were invited to complete a self-report survey consisting of three questionnaires for emotion regulation, psychological well-being at work, and work engagement. Correlation and regression were calculated using SPSS 29 to investigate the relationship between the variables. The findings showed that compared to emotion regulation, psychological well-being at work was the biggest predictor of variance in work engagement. Between emotion regulation aspects, reappraisal was found to have the biggest impact on work engagement variance. Regarding psychological well-being at work domains, thriving at work had the most significant predictive link with work engagement. The research examining specific roles of psychological well-being at work is limited, and the present study adds knowledge to this field. By investigating the predictive relationship between emotion regulation and psychological well-being at work with work engagement, this study demonstrates the importance of considering English teachers’ emotions and well-being in order to foster their engagement with the teaching profession. Future research could include teachers’ age, gender, and years of experience, which were not measured in this research to further investigate their roles in teachers’ work engagement. More longitudinal studies are also needed to investigate the causal relationship between variables.
The current findings suggest the importance of considering Indonesian English teachers’ emotions and well-being in relation to their work engagement. Teachers’ work engagement has been found to be linked with several positive outcomes, such as higher job satisfaction, positive career aspirations, and increased participation in non-core roles. Emotion regulation and psychological well-being at work of English teachers in Indonesian English teachers are found to predict work engagement. In order to provide teachers with the skills they need to manage, and ideally, thrive in their chosen profession over the long term, it would be vital to integrate well-being competencies into teacher education programs in Indonesia. For instance, pre-service and in-service teacher training programs would benefit from providing educators with the self-regulatory and socioemotional competencies required to regulate their own levels of stress, emotions, motivation, and overall professional well-being. Moreover, as this study found that positive emotional experiences can be linked to teachers’ work engagement, the intervention program can focus on training teachers to be more aware of their positive emotions in the classroom as these emotions would benefit their well-being. However, these training and intervention programs should be implemented with caution as participating in such programs may increase teachers’ workload and thus may increase teachers’ stress (van Wingerden et al., 2013). Additionally, some teachers could be reluctant to take part in these interventions given that they are frequently planned by the same administrators whom some teachers believed to be responsible for teachers’ initial heavy workloads (Granziera et al., 2021). Therefore, interventions and training programs must be tailored to the needs of teachers and carried out in a way that enables teachers to see the direct advantages for themselves and their profession.
Exploring the relationship between school moral atmosphere and moral identity
- Student
- Secondary
- Survey
- Adolescents
- Education and Language
- Perspectives
This study was done as current national educational policy regarding moral development is limited in guidance regarding how schools could support moral development, therefore this study aimed to explore the relationship between adolescents’ perception of their school’s moral atmosphere and how important they personally think showing moral behaviours is. This study seeks to contribute to wider academic discussions surrounding moral education by providing empirical data regarding adolescents’ perception of their school’s indirect moral messaging. The target population for the study were older adolescents, aged 16-18 years old. This age group were selected due to this group being able to reflect on their full time at secondary school, and also due to adolescence being identified as an important period for the emergence of moral identity. 12 participants took part in an online survey with 51 questions. These questions asked them to rate on a 5-point scale, where 1=Strongly Disagree and 5= Strongly Agree, how much they agreed with statements about their approach to different situations and also about their perceptions of their school. Participants were recruited through social media groups on Facebook and via the social media application TikTok. Participants were also recruited via initial participants distributing the survey to other people within the target population. This study found that there was no significant relationship between rating of school moral atmosphere and moral identity. The data showed a moderate negative relationship between perception of social relations within school and moral integrity. These findings indicate that adolescents who rate the social relations within their secondary school lower are expected to have higher moral integrity scores. This goes against previous research that found a positive relationship between similar variables of moral competency and social relationships. However, it should be considered that the participants in this study all experienced significant disruption to their learning during the past two years due to the COVID-19 pandemic. This may have affected to their rating of their school moral atmosphere, as they may have had brief periods of online learning along with less consistent access to their regular physical school environments. Replications of this study could adopt a mixed methods approach, with the use of the two measures in this study and also interviewing participants to explore how they perceive their school moral atmosphere in the aftermath of the peak of the pandemic compared to prior to the pandemic.
I think teachers and adolescents would benefit from this research. As discussed in the literature review, there is a lot of freedom, but also lack of clarity regarding best practises for provision for moral development within schools. From the findings of this study, I would highlight one key point for educators to consider within their classrooms and wider school. The findings of this study suggests that adolescents’ perception of social relations and sense of community within the school decreases if they place a higher value on acting in a way that is consistent with their personal moral values. This may indicate that adolescents’ feel that their personal moral values may not align with the moral atmosphere promoted by their school as an institution and as a community. Educators could adopt aspects of the Just Community approach to engage with their older pupils to discuss their moral values and what has contributed to these values being internalised. This may be achieved within classrooms through supported moral discussions between pupils and between pupils and teachers (Boheim et al., 2021), and also within the wider school environment through allowing pupils to help shape school ethos’ and behaviour codes. For adolescents, this study is impactful through acknowledging the value of their perspectives on their school environment. The School Moral Atmosphere Questionnaire emphasises that adolescents are engaged and important social actors within their school environment, therefore their perspectives are valuable to consider when considering non-academic educational policy that aims to support their personal development. Additionally, the findings could be interpreted as schools not having an impact on adolescents’ moral development. Further research using qualitative methods could provide an insight into what institutions or aspects of society adolescents feel contribute to their moral development, which then could be reflected in changes to current guidance for moral development provision in schools and wider socio-political discussion regarding adolescents and their morality.
Exploring the role of activating knowledge in Year 1 maths lessons
- Learning environment
- Qualitative
- Teacher
- Mainstream
- Teaching and learning
- Education and Language
How knowledge is constructed, who decides what is taught, and when and how it is measured have long governed discussions around educational policy. Yet, dialogue around how our ‘knowledge-rich’ national curriculum sits within its contemporary, cultural context is far quieter. This dissertation reports on an inquiry into activating knowledge during maths lessons in a Year 1 setting in Greater Manchester. It explores themes of knowledge and power, place-based education and how these work in relation to activating knowledge. Qualitative data gleaned from student voice indicates that students are building their knowledge of maths far wider than school, revealing a plethora of ‘hidden’ adults and places. This makes the case for teachers building their awareness of students’ contexts and how these intersect with learning opportunities, especially in early education and especially where their socio-demographics differ to those of the school. Furthermore, this study found that one government-endorsed maths scheme does not match some research recommendations for how prior knowledge is most effectively activated through structural as opposed to surface tasks. This indicates that school bought schemes and subscriptions should not be blindly accepted, rather, subject to teacher discretion and adaption for student need. Finally, this project indicates that leading models of cognitive architecture and activation of knowledge, upon which policy is in at least part predicated, don’t yet adequately capture the idiosyncrasies and fluidity of knowledge in ways that can be monitored and used effectively in a classroom of Year 1 students. As these models form part of the dominant discourse of learning, there can only be benefit in apportioning space for teachers to learn more about the origins of ideas, the contexts in which they are used and their underlying ambiguities.
Visual depiction of impact is provided:


Exploring the self-perceptions of mathematical ability and aspritions in high attaining Key Stage Four female pupils.
- Qualitative
- Secondary
- Focus group
- Mathematics
- Education and Language
- Perspectives
Since the Enlightenment, the notion of scientific rationality and abstraction has been closely associated with the male gender more so than the female. Mathematics is seen as a subject that deals with the abstract using rational logical methods of inquiry. Transitively, then in mathematics has become known as a subject more suited for males to pursue as a career. Societal stereotypes and narratives in a patriarchal society have propagated this association throughout history through the use of binary oppositions that privilege the personality traits commonly associated with the male gender. What effect, therefore, has this had on female pupils studying mathematics? This research explores the influences on the self-perceptions of mathematical ability of high attaining female pupils during their GCSE years of study. In my professional life as a teacher and through news reports on every GCSE results day, we find that female pupils are just as good as, if not better than, male pupils in GCSE subjects. However, when we look at a level participation, we find that a notable majority of mathematics students are males. What is happening to those high attaining girls so that they do well in GCSE mathematics, but decide not to pursue mathematics at A Level? As well as analysing and explaining how self-perceptions affect mathematical aspirations, we will also compare female self-perceptions with male self-perceptions of mathematical ability. This will allow us to evaluate the extent to which this dualistic opposition thinking from the Enlightenment still permeates contemporary societal thinking about mathematics attainment and aspirations. This research aims to answer two research questions: 1. How do high attaining female pupils perceive their own mathematical ability and aspirations? 2. What is the difference between self-perceptions of mathematical ability and aspirations in high attaining male and female pupils? Through the use of pupil questionnaires and pupil focus groups, the notion of gender socialisation, intersecting with GCSE mathematics lessons is analysed. How the different gender groups view this socialisation and the influence on their mathematical aspirations (or lack thereof) were evaluated to conclude whether archaic gender stereotypes about mathematics as being a ‘male subject’ is still affecting high attaining students.
The community I have chosen for my Dissemination of Impact presentation is the mathematics department at my school of employment. The reason I have chosen them is because my research is an exploration into the self perceptions of some of our pupils. Recent narratives in education have focused on white, working class boys or engage low attainers, however, as my research has shown, high attaining girls also need focusing on. The purpose of my research was to find out about the self perceptions of my high attaining class and why it was that they were not choosing to do A level maths in college. This was a problem, not just in my high attaining classes, but others too (as shown by the pupil questionnaires I conducted). Therefore, my findings and recommendations are extremely relev ant to
my mathematics colleagues in school, as they can then use my research to inform their own practice. By using the recommendations, and reflecting on the ideas that I have discussed, they can better their own teaching so that they can become a more feminist teacher. The effect of this should be that narratives in our school that exclude girls, or treat maths as a subject for boys, will be eradicated. Hence, high attaining girls have a more positive self perception of mathematical ability and feel empowered to take maths at A level if they so wish. If the department wish to implement my recommendations and use the issues I have raised to further reflect on our teaching practice and the way we talk about mathematics, then the effect should be a more inclusive classroom, where female (high attaining) pupils feel more open to the possibility of continuing with mathematics study post GCSE.


Exploring the use of nurture groups and nurture principles in UK education systems: from the perspectives of teaching staff
- Interview
- Qualitative
- Teacher
- Education
- Wellbeing
- Emotion
- Education and Language
This study explored the impact of NG provision and nurture principles from the perspectives of teaching staff. Research has shown the potential benefits of the implementation of nurture groups (NGs) and nurture principles for children’s social and emotional wellbeing. There are also many government policies showing the importance of providing safe, nurturing environments for children to learn in. Despite this knowledge, many schools continue to use punitive approaches as opposed to those which are restorative or nurturing in approach. The target population were various members of teaching staff located across the UK with an understanding of nurture provision within their school setting. The sample included ten participants with varying roles such as teachers, nurture leaders and educational consultants. Participants were interviewed via zoom to address the research questions of study which included: the impact on class teachers, children with social, emotional, mental health (SEMH) needs, the class climate and challenges surrounding nurture provision. The findings suggest that implementation of NGs and nurture principles can support teacher wellbeing, social and emotional development of pupils with SEMH needs, and improve the classroom environment in various ways. Challenges surrounding nurture provision were identified, including barriers to communication and perception from school staff. Findings of this study were consistent with those of relevant research which highlighted the numerous benefits of nurture provision which include improved social and emotional communication skills, attainment, and the importance of whole-school approaches. Future research could explore the perspectives of pupils with SEMH needs and their families to gain a further insight into the importance of nurture provision.
As there is more responsibility on schools and staff to support the mental health and wellbeing of pupils in education, there is a need for more research to understand effective ways of supporting students and benefits associated with different interventions. There are many impacts of this study on areas such as impacts on school approaches, teacher support and general policies and practice within education. This research will benefit schools as it encourages the use of nurturing approaches as opposed to punitive approaches, which have been shown to be detrimental to children’s wellbeing. By encouraging a shift in the way teachers respond to challenging behaviour and understanding the nurture principle ‘all behaviour is communication’, children will be able to reach their full potential. This study has many educational benefits such as showing the need for nurturing and safe environments, an understanding of attachment and the creation of more restorative nurturing policies. This would also be beneficial for teaching staff and schools as it encourages awareness and understanding of effective ways to utilise nurture principles to support all students in the school, in particular those with SEMH needs. This would create a whole-school inclusive environment. It is hoped that this research study will encourage teaching staff and school SLT to re-evaluate their strategies in terms of managing and supporting children’s behaviour, given the findings regarding nurturing approaches.
Facilitating a Sense of Belonging in Asylum-Seeking and Refugee Primary School Children: The Perspectives of UK Teachers
- English as an additional language EAL
- Interview
- Qualitative
- Wellbeing
- Emotion
- Refugee
- Education and Language
The aim of this study was to explore the factors that affected primary school ASR students’ sense of belonging in their new schools and communities. This study explored the perceptions of teachers, rather than the ASR students themselves. Teachers are closely involved and familiar with the school system, therefore their insights could provide great detail on changes that could facilitate this belonging at a school level. Research showed that belonging was essential for any ASR students’ transition into their new schools and communities. Additionally, past studies showed that various systems in an individual’s life including their peers, family, teachers, and wider community greatly impact their feelings of belonging. The study aimed to explore teachers’ perceptions of the factors that affect ASR students’ belonging and steps that can be taken to overcome any barriers. The target population included primary school teachers or teaching assistants in the UK who have taught ASR students for at least a year. The sample for the study included 8 teachers; 6 females and 2 males between the ages of 24 and 39. One teacher was based in Glasgow, three in Manchester, two in Birmingham, and one in Bradford. Out of these teachers, all of them identified as British/White except for two, who both identified as Asian. After obtaining consent from the participants, they were invited to attend an online interview to discuss their thoughts. Semi-structured interviews were used with some pre-prepared questions that were formulated through existing studies, whilst simultaneously allowing for flexibility in answering the questions based on the participant responses. The interview reponses were analysed through methods of Thematic Analysis, which uncovered certain themes and subthemes to answer the research questions. The findings showed four major themes that affected an ASR students’ sense of belonging: Student Upbringing, Psychological Well-being and Resilience, Ecosystems of Support, and Inclusive School Practices. These themes drew upon the bio-psycho-socio-ecological model, which highlighted the importance of a holistic approach to fostering a sense of belonging among ASR students. The findings also emphasised that teachers’ perceptions of their own roles, as well as their readiness to accommodate to ASR students in their class, affected the efforts that they put into promoting a sense of belongingness. This ties in with the literature on self-efficacy, explaining that teachers’ beliefs in their own abilities significantly affect student motivation, feelings of belonging, and educational outcomes. Finally, the findings highlighted the importance that school systems have to create a welcoming and inclusive environment for ASR students. Teachers also stated that their own beliefs in the abilities to help ASR students would increase if schools provided additional resources and training to teachers to assist teachers to accommodate the needs of ASR students. The key recommendations provided by this study involve changes made from various surrounding networks in the ASR child’s life. It is crucial to integrate them into their new communities while preserving their cultural identities. Parents play a pivotal role, impacting their children's sense of belonging through their own integration. Peer relationships, even with language barriers, are vital, facilitated by extracurricular activities. Teachers must prepare and seek additional resources and training to boost self-efficacy. Schools should provide continuous support, starting before enrollment, and aid teachers with training, resources, and additional staff. Whole-school changes, such as integrating ASR topics and enhancing cultural representation, promote inclusivity. In conclusion, promoting ASR students' belonging requires a comprehensive approach and collaborative efforts across support systems to create an inclusive school and community.
The research findings hold significant implications and recommendations. By implementing the strategies outlined in the research, schools can create more inclusive and welcoming environments for ASR students. This can result in improved educational outcomes and a greater sense of belonging among ASR students. Teachers can benefit from this research by gaining insights into how they can better support ASR students. They can adapt their classroom practices and create a positive environment to accommodate the diverse backgrounds and needs of ASR students. Parents of students can benefit from this research by understanding the importance of their involvement in their children's sense of belonging. They can actively engage with schools, attend cultural events, and support their children's integration. Additionally, the broader community and the general public can benefit from this research as it promotes fostering a more harmonious society. At a policy and governmental level, policymakers in the Department of Education can consider implementing these suggestions to schools all around the UK to promote inclusion, and can consider the importance of funding training and resources to support ASR students. All of the findings tie together essential to support ASR students, who are the primary beneficiaries. The research suggests that by fostering a sense of belonging, ASR students can have a smoother transition into their new communities, allowing them to feel more valued and integrated.
Home Learning Environments for Pupil-Premium Eligible Children: An Analysis of Parent Perspectives and Practice in the Northwest
- Interview
- Qualitative
- Parent
- Education
- Education and Language
Some caregivers who experience poverty and disadvantage find it difficult to engage in learning activities with the children in their care, which can lead to poorer educational and social outcomes for the child. This study intended to find out more about this from the perspective of those who are affected. Therefore, low-income individuals living in an area of the Northwest with high poverty rates were requested to participate in the study. Eight parents were interviewed and described their perspectives, experiences, barriers, and support relevant to the learning activities they engage in with their children. The researcher analysed these interviews and generated themes that were common across them. It was discovered that although low-income parents know how important home engagement is, they face many barriers when it comes to engaging with their children at home. These included the cost of resources, inaccessible transport, and their own mental or physical health difficulties. Parents also described feeling like they do not receive enough support from the government or from schools. This research project supports findings about the relationship between income and home engagement as it provides some explanations for why learning at home can become difficult. It is also supportive of some researchers who claim that low-income caregivers can feel excluded or alienated from the school context. The government, too, admit to failings in this area. However, it does not support some findings that argue that home engagement may be lower for low-income households because of reduced levels of motivation by the caregivers. Schools, caregivers, and government organisations should work collaboratively to create support programs as there are many factors that can hinder a caregiver’s ability to engage at home. By improving home engagement, children and young people can expect to see better outcomes in and outside of school.
The government has acknowledged its shortcomings in providing adequate support for home learning and plans to invest in research to determine the efficacy of specific interventions. It is also essential to gather feedback from those most at risk to ensure that the support provided is useful and accessible. Without this perspective, the implementation of support will be ineffective. The education sector would also benefit from the results of this study. Work needs to be done to create better channels of communication between schools, community groups, and caregivers to facilitate home learning and to ensure the responsibility does not fall solely on disadvantaged households who may not have the appropriate knowledge, experience, or resources to aid their child’s learning outside of school. Wider awareness of the benefits of home learning to the general Parent Experiences of the Home Learning Environment public may also improve engagement; children and young people may then experience improved social and educational outcomes overall. Parents also described the negative impact of poor local facilities. This research could therefore potentially encourage local government groups to improve local facilities such as libraries and parks, thus creating a positive environmental impact. This research could also benefit the education and culture sectors if schools commit to improving their awareness of barriers, the impact of stigma and better methods of communication to facilitate learning beyond the school building.
How do self-esteem and peer relationships relate to and influence academic disengagement, in UK adolescents (11-16) in full-time education?
- Quantitative
- Education and Language
- adolescents
- Self-esteem
- peer acceptance
- school disengagement
- Survey
- Secondary
If There’s A Will, Is There A Way? A Case Study on University Lecturers’ Readiness to Support Autistic Students
- Interview
- Teacher
- Education
- Higher education
- Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND)
- Policy
- Perspectives
About a year before writing this dissertation, I stumbled across a University of Birmingham article titled: “Mind the gap: What is missing in the autism research agenda?” in which I read a poignant story of Jim Simpson: “Jim Simpson, an autistic author and activist in the US, tells a story of meeting a child with autism. The child was amazed to meet Jim. Having never heard of an adult who had autism, he had assumed that autistic children died before they grew up.” Reading this made me realise that I had an integral role in ensuring that all children believe they will grow up and can blossom in their own space. My dissertation's main aim was to better understand how lecturers support autistic university students, specifically at the University of Manchester. This was done by answering two key questions: Q1: How does university lecturers’ awareness and understanding of autism correlate with their ability to support autistic students? and Q2: What critical pedagogical strategies do university lecturers employ to support the diverse academic and social needs of autistic students? As a case study, this dissertation used semi-structured interviews to interview four lecturers in our University's Education field. Data were then inductively and thematically analysed. The findings reflect that: 1. Lecturers are adept at naming autistic traits and the varied presentation of autism, 2. Lecturers have minimal experience with autistic students, 3. Lecturers rarely have access to inclusion-related training, and more bespoke autism training needs to be provided to lecturers, 4. Lecturers have different ways of equipping themselves with skills to support autistic students, 5. Lecturers display high levels of willingness to support students, and 6. Lecturers highlight that all university stakeholders must contribute to developing an autism-friendly university. All of the findings can also be seen in the illustrated materials below. Therefore, taking inspiration from lecturers’ interview responses, the dissertation proposes plausible, practical changes for the university in this case study. Possible university-wide changes are as follows: 1. To adopt the Autism & Uni framework or develop a bespoke autism training, 2. To facilitate more university-wide conversations about intersectional autistic identities and recognise good staff support practices, and 3. To create dedicated spaces and visibility for autistic students and academics. However, it must be noted that, once again, due to the heterogeneity of autism and how universities operate differently, this suggestion is only applicable as a response to the findings of this dissertation as a case study. Moreover, research in this area is still sparse and collective efforts, involving autistic students themselves, can be a great way to begin tapping into best inclusive practices in higher education. For example, future research might decide to conduct university-specific focus groups with lecturers and autistic students, bridging any knowledge gap and co-creating materials to support autistic students.
At a glance, my dissertation is particularly important for key decision-makers at any given British university. From time constraints to sheer lack of knowledge, the dissertation illuminates some vital changes needed with university-wide inclusion training and support for staff. To support a marginalised group of students, we have to support the staff who are the gateway to these students’ success in education. If anything, the dissertation emphasised that lecturing staff are highly willing to support students but that universities are required to help pave the way for this to happen. On another note, this research contributes to an existing (albeit small) pool of participatory papers on autism. As an autistic person, more people (autistic or not) need to be able to read research written with some lived experiences in mind. One of the key things identified in the literature review leading up to this complete research found that autistic researchers are implicitly barred from writing ‘research that matters’ due to research bureaucracy and fears of getting the research methods ‘just right’. In consulting with writings from established autistic researchers in various fields, a 2022 paper by autistic research by Sandra Jones forefronts this debate, ensuring me that asking meaningful questions can be as valuable as being able to use technically complex research methods. Moreover, this research aims to reach children like those mentioned in Jim Simpson’s story. Currently, degree completion rates of autistic students are lower than those of who are non-autistic; employment rates also prove a similar gap. If someone as reading this summary and could feel a flicker of hope that good work is being done in higher education (HE) to make sure that people like them (or rather, like us) can be in HE, then this research has had its intended impact. Creating meaningful research requires all types of individuals, and I would not be at University writing my dissertation today if it were not for pioneers before me. Equally, if we carry any form of privilege with us, we must acknowledge it and use it to liberate others who are less able to do so. The Education research world might appear small and tight-knit, but it is wide enough for all of us.
Prize - Best Dissertation for BSc Education

Imposter Syndrome Amongst Higher Education Students and its Impacts on Psychological Wellbeing and Academic Contingencies of Self-Worth: Testing Direct and Indirect Pathways
- Quantitative
- wellbeing
- Education and Language
- Survey
- University students
- academic self-worth
- Self-report questionnaire
- Mediation analysis
- Higher Education
Including Children with Down Syndrome in the Classroom
- Primary
- Education and Language
- Inclusion
- Down Syndrome
In this summary of my poster I will discuss methods of including children with Down syndrome in the classroom, highlighting both the strengths they bring and challenges they may face and effective strategies that can be implemented. I will explore the importance of providing access to an age appropriate curriculum and the impact this has on children with Down syndrome. My focus on the inclusion of pupils with Down syndrome is due to my own strong personal understanding of Down syndrome and my experience of working with primary school pupils with Down syndrome. Cleveland Clinic (2023) define Down Syndrome as being a genetic condition where a person is born with an extra chromosome. This can affect how their brain and body develop. People diagnosed with Down syndrome have happy and healthy lives with supportive care. Similar to the definition provided on my poster, I have found that the majority of definitions I came across were consistent differing only on their tone, sometimes reflecting the authors assumptions or opinions about Down syndrome and a persons abilities because of it.
I intend for the poster to stress the importance that people should not assume that a child with Down syndrome is incapable of learning in a mainstream classroom along with their peers. Children with Down syndrome may face barriers in the classroom but with the right support and opportunities, they will succeed.
With this being said inclsuion of a child with Down syndrome goes beyond physical presence in the classroom with a one-to-one teaching assistant (TA), solely working on individual tasks. Teachers should provide children with Down syndrome with a level of education to the same standard that any other child in the class would receive. Equipping them to overcome any challenges they may encounter. Fox, Farrell and Davis (2004) carried out a study on effective inclusion of primary aged pupils with Down syndrome, they found that inclusion is more likely to be successful when the class teacher takes a central role in the management of support and the organisation of a child’s daily educational experiences, this a vital point. TA’s play a significant role in inclusion however it is the teacher who is qualified and therefore responsible to plan for and implement strategies appropriate for inclusion.
If TA support is provided as a constant one to one basis, this will restrict opportunities for the child (Alton, 2021). I have seen first hand the results of a TA remaining attached to a child with Down Syndrome throughout the school day, while well intended the child became reliant on this constant support and was reluctant to undertake independent tasks that required them to use their own problem solving skills and even interacting with peers. One to one support unintentionally creates a dependency on the adult.
One of the most prevalent challenges that children with Down syndrome face is difficulties in producing accurate speech. Pettinato and Verhoeven ( 2009) suggest that language impairment is an inherent characteristic of Down syndrome independent of the learning difficulties associated with the syndrome. This contrasts with the statement in my poster from Burgoyne, Buckley and Baxter (2021) reporting that speech difficulties are related to age and to vocabulary and reading skills. While I acknowledge Pettinato and Verhoeven’s (2009) statement that language difficulties are not influenced by developmental and educational factors, I also recognise the importance of teachers actively working to overcome difficulties in speech production. Speech difficulties can be incredibly debilitating for some children, they often result in frustration and social isolation.
Oral communication can be encouraged through reading with the child. Reading makes language visual and conflictingly is often an area where children with Down syndrome exceed expectations, it is a skill that can be consistently developed to a practical level (Alton, 2021). This strength can be leveraged to promote accurate speech production, reading with the child and providing them with prompts has been proven to result in gains in language development (Burgoyne & Cain, 2020.) I recognise that some people are hesitant to interpret what pupils with Down syndrome who have speech difficulties are communicating in concern they will misunderstand. It is important to be patient and take time to listen. The more you engage with the child, your ear will adjust to their way of speaking enabling you to provide more effective support.
The National Curriculum states that “Teachers should set high expectations for every pupil.” (Department For Education, 2013). This includes children with Special Educational Needs (SEN) and children with Down syndrome. Teachers should recognise pupils with Down syndrome’s strengths and encourage the child to develop these further, setting them challenging tasks across the curriculum. Studies indicate that teachers perceptions of children with Down syndrome have a significant impact on the child’s success (Bills & Mills, 2020). Connecting this back to my poster it further expands on my point of importance in fostering a growth mindset in pupils with Down syndrome, like any child they will thrive in a classroom where they feel they belong and their strengths acknowledged."
I have addressed the importance of including children with Down syndrome in the primary classroom. I have recognized their strengths and strategies in supporting them to achieve their goals. At the same time I have addressed common challenges children with Down syndrome may experience and effective strategies to ensure the children can access an age appropriate curriculum. I have explored the concept of an inclusive education in a more general sense, drawing on relevant literature and information from the taught course to examine different perspectives. By taking these viewpoints into account I have been able to relate my own experiences and deepen my understanding of what an inclusive education truly is. An environment where all pupils are valued and supported to reach their potential regardless of their background, race or ability. A key takeaway for my professional development is the notion from Adderley et al. (2015) inclusion is a dynamic process and not a static position, combining this point with the literature reviewed I understand that creating an inclusive classroom is a continuous process that requires constant effort, I will trial various strategies including those I have discussed and seen used effectively, while acknowledging that these may not work for all pupils. This assignment has reinforced the imporance of individualised approaches. I am aware that it is I, the teacher, who is responsible for ensuring that my classroom is an inclusive environment, recognizing the level of needs, race, background, sex, and SEMH of all students and fostering an atmosphere of acceptance and respect among the class. This is an essential step in ensuring the pupils succeed academically, socially and emotionally.

Insights into Resilience: How Person-Centred and Social-Ecological Understandings Inform Resilience Development Practices and Collaboration in Alternative Provision
- Interview
- adolescent
- resilience
- Qualitative
- Secondary
- Education and Language
Investigating how students and teachers at an International School Experience the use of technology to support learning in secondary mathematics.
- Digital
- Learning environment
- Student
- Secondary
- Mainstream
- Digital Learning
- Perspectives
This dissertation explores students' and teachers' perceptions of technology's role in the secondary mathematics classroom. The research used a case study approach to focus on individuals’ views and experiences of using technology to support learning in the case school, where heavy emphasis was placed on using technology in classes. The study aimed to contribute rich, small-sample contextual data to existing research and build on existing research conclusions in the field of education technology. The research demonstrated how students and teachers both aspired to use the technology to access and provide, respectively, more direct and personalised learning than traditional methods would allow. Technology was used in the case school by teachers to leverage students’ engagement and motivation, while both parties leveraged aspects of the technology to improve the accessibility of learning. Students used technology to gain more autonomy and independence. Key barriers and limitations were the high demands on infrastructure to support the technology, friction with the traditional classroom, and the prevalence of off-task student behaviour. The study concluded that to realise the perceived benefits of the technology used in the case school, there must be thorough and precise training in the technology for both teachers and students, an explicit understanding of the benefits and drawbacks of technology that could be leveraged when planning programs of learning, and robust infrastructure.
I disseminated my findings and recommendations to SLT at the case school. This is because these individuals have the capability to enact the recommendations, should they be persuaded. They also do not necessarily have daily first-hand experiences or oversight of how technology is being used around the school, due to the high-autonomy norms of the school and could benefit from the insight given by this research. I had met with some key members of the leadership them – the head teacher, the head of secondary, and the head of maths – before embarking on my project, to discuss and be transparent about my research as I would be using school time and access in part to complete it.At this time, they expressed interest in project and I would like to show my appreciation by involving them in this final stage. SLT has a need to plan effectively with knowledge of how technology is being used in the school. SLT is responsible for planning continuous improvement by making key decisions about the curriculum, staff development and resourcing. In my research, I provide SLT with this insight and knowledge. I also make recommendations, based on the findings, about how this planning and decision-making could be most effective. I have generated knowledge on how to improve the effectiveness of technology in the case school, by drawing upon the experiences and perceptions of individuals in the case school who interact with it daily. I have provided SLT with information about how technology is currently being used and perceived in the school, the potential for its development and how we might begin to bridge this gap. The knowledge will impact this audience by giving them the means to recognise and work towards achieving the potential of technology in the case school. The audience here is in a unique position to achieve this due to the school’s existing priority focus and heavy resourcing for technology. SLT can recognise the impact of my study by enacting the recommendations I set out: initially by acknowledging the findings of the study in determining the value and best use of technology, and then by following the further recommendations on how to realise this in context.
Investigating the effectiveness of using the video-mediated flipped classroom to enhance student engagement in the IELTS speaking and writing classroom.
- Student Engagement
- Mixed Methods research
- Digital
- Observation
- Flipped Classroom (FC)
- Foreign Language Learning
A great number of Chinese students continue to speak mute English and struggle to write in English after learning this language for many years. The reasons for the poor productive skills are suggested to be related to insufficient practice in the classroom and limited opportunities to use them in everyday life. Research has shown FC may be able to improve students’ language skills by increasing their engagement with learning both in and outside of the classroom. This research aims to investigate the effectiveness of FC in enhancing student engagement and their attitudes towards this mode of learning in IELTS speaking and writing classes in the Chinese higher education context. A mixed research method including observations, questionnaires, and semi-structured interviews was utilised to obtain data from the teacher’s and students’ perspectives. After triangulating the data obtained from observing 15 students and their responses from 13 questionnaires and 11 semi-structured interviews in both the IELTS speaking and writing classes, the findings of this research show FC can enhance student emotional and social engagement, and students perceive positive attitudes towards this mode of learning. But more research is needed to further understand whether FC can enhance student behaviour and cognitive engagement.
The results indicate FC is able to enhance student learning time outside of the classroom; the time for group work, class discussions, practice, and feedback in class is also increased, which is likely to enhance learning effects.
It’s time to talk: a case study investigation into teacher views on CPD in the teaching of English, across a range of career points.
- Interview
- Teacher
- Survey
- Mainstream
- Education
- Teaching and learning
- Education and Language
- Perspectives
The consensus that CPD is key to school reform means that it is necessary to investigate teacher experiences of and attitudes towards CPD. The definition of CPD is contested in the field, and there are debates as to whether it should be evidence-based, internal or external to the school, time-rich or time-poor, and if it really improves student outcomes. Despite these conflicts, research reveals that teachers of all career stages are rarely asked about their views on CPD even though they are the participants of it. Therefore, this thesis presents the findings of a pilot case study (undertaken within approximately 7 months by a researcher-practitioner in a North-West England academy) of 8 purposively sampled participants which assesses how teachers of all career stages feel towards the CPD they experience as part of their professional work. After thematically analysing data generated generating through questionnaires and interview, the study reveals that teachers have varying, inconsistent CPD experiences. Nonetheless, teachers view CPD as a vital tool to improve as a professional and their desire for good CPD rarely wavers across career stages. Teachers admit to external influences like time and psychological pressures impacting their attitudes towards CPD, but still viewed CPD as something which can, and should, benefit them. Teachers seemed to value colleague-to-colleague support above all else – even their strong desire for CPD that helps them achieve day-to-day tasks. This suggests that all teachers should have a mentor/coach style support, allowing colleagues to support and challenge each other to create the best CPD. The disparities between teachers at different career stages also revealed that CPD should be monitored across one’s career, allowing it to shift to cater to individual, ever-changing needs. Ultimately, the study reveals that to become the best practitioners, teachers need bespoke CPD that caters to individual needs.
Visual depiction of impact is provided:




LGBTQ+ provision in UK secondary schools: A qualitative exploration into teachers’ perceptions of the microaggressions experienced by LGBTQ+ students
- Qualitative
- Teacher
- LGBTQ+
- Student
- Education and Language
- Perspectives
This research aimed to explore teachers’ perceptions and understanding of microaggressions, targeted towards LGBTQ+ students. Microaggressions are behaviours that define subtle forms of discrimination, frequently communicating hostile or derogatory beliefs either intentionally or unintentionally (Nadal, 2013; Sue, 2010). Nine teachers were interviewed, sharing their perceptions of the discrimination LGBTQ+ students currently face within UK secondary schools. This involved discussing the types and frequency of discrimination observed by teachers from students towards LGBTQ+ students, whilst also discussing the perceived impacts of these instances on LGBTQ+ students' wellbeing. Teachers were chosen as the target population of this study in order to gain insight into their understanding of LGBTQ+ student experiences within schools, shedding light on the lack of concrete guidance provided within both school policies and teacher training. Teachers were interviewed over Zoom, with interviews lasting around 40 minutes. These interviews were then transcribed and analysed through Thematic Analysis. From the data analysis, the following three themes were uncovered: (1) acknowledgement of heteronormativity, (2) awareness of microaggressions and (3) school support. Heteronormativity refers to the belief that people fall into distinct genders of either male or female, and that this gender aligns with their biological sex; therefore discounting the existence of other gender identities, sexualities and gender roles (Page & Peacock, 2013). Within theme 1, varied awareness of heteronormativity within schools was demonstrated by teachers. Some often acknowledged its prominence by providing examples such as the lack of consideration when grouping students by their sex on a school trip, however failing to selfreflect on their own teaching practices by not recognising potential instances of heteronormativity within their own teaching. Others showed little to no awareness of the term, also failing to recognise the detrimental impacts of a heteronormative environment on LGBTQ+ students. Within this theme, teachers recognised that bisexual and transgender identities are less normalised than heterosexual, gay and lesbian identities, falling in line with existing research. Nevertheless, positive changes in acceptance over time were also recognised by teachers, with discussion often expressing how teachers feel able to be more open about their own sexual and gender identities within schools, in turn leading to more normalisation towards LGBTQ+ identities amongst students throughout schools. Theme 2 found teachers to have a non-conceptualised understanding of microaggressions, however, teachers were able to provide examples of these instances, whilst showing a cohesive understanding of the impact microaggressions can have on students. Nevertheless, a lack of standardisation amongst reactions to anti-LGBTQ+ behaviours was suggested by teachers as they described how they would manage a situation. Theme 3, school support, found that teachers recognise the importance of LGBTQ+ groups in normalising LGBTQ+ identities and providing students with a ‘safe space’ for support. Other positive school influences were found to be school policies, positive student attitudes, students' age and maturity and teachers’ knowledge. All teachers demonstrated a wish for further teacher training in LGBTQ+ support, particularly surrounding terminology and pronouns. Future research into microaggressions from a student’s experience is suggested, whilst research is also needed to understand the reasoning behind school’s lack of engagement with current literature and practical strategies (e.g., Russel et al., 2021) that it provides in further supporting LGBTQ+ students.
Benefiters of this research includes teachers and educational providers as it aims to raise awareness of microaggressions, whilst providing suggestions for how to better support LGBTQ+ students within the heteronormative school environment. Recommendations for legislation and school policies are also suggested by teachers throughout the interviews, as they describe the need for less ambiguity and more practical suggestions for implementing policy into their teaching practices. For example, current training and policy are described as including ‘buzz words’ and ‘umbrella terms’ of inclusion and diversity, whilst failing to provide applicable solutions to students struggling with discrimination from their peers and/or needing support with their own identity. Further teacher training was also found to be needed by all teachers interviewed, with several teachers expressing a wish for more case study training, further providing more applicability to their own teaching practices. Teachers also expressed a wish for teacher training to be provided by individuals with their own experiences of navigating their own LGBTQ+ identity, having their own experiences of antiLGBTQ+ behaviours; thus, making them better able to direct teachers toward the necessary steps that need to be taken to better support students. By targeting LGBTQ+ acceptance and normalisation within secondary schools, this research aims to further promote a culture of inclusion and acceptance towards diversity, prompting societal changes towards increased LGBTQ+ acceptance.
‘Like no one ever talks about it, so you sort of downplay it all’ Young people’s perceptions and emotional experiences of Climate Change Education in the UK.
- Qualitative
- Secondary
- Adolescents
- Focus group
- Education and Language
- Perspectives
This project aimed to find out what young people, aged 16 -18, thought about being taught about climate change. Previous research has suggested that young people could find the issue of climate change upsetting, so the project also aimed to look at their emotional responses to the topic. The study involved young people taking part in a group discussion about their experiences of being taught about climate change and how they think the topic could be taught in the future. After the discussion they put their ideas about how climate change could be taught in the future into a mind map. Twenty-five young people from colleges in Greater Manchester took part in the study. There were three focus groups held, with between eleven and six participants in each. After the focus group the researcher made transcripts of the discussions by listening to a recording of the focus group and typing up what young people said, without attempting to ‘correct’ their language or grammar. Then the researcher carefully read all the transcripts and mind maps to become familiar with what had been said. Then these were coded, which involves going through the documents line by line and summarising the meaning of each line. Codes which had a shared meaning were grouped together, for example codes that referred to role-models. These groups of codes were used to produce four themes to describe what the young people as a group had reported about their experiences of being taught about climate change. The findings showed that young people knew about climate change but that they had a complex relationship with the issue. Both college and media had provided them with information. However, this information was not deep, and the images shown in the media gave them a negative impression of climate change. They also saw it as a global problem, which they wanted governments to help tackle. Currently they did not think that governments were doing enough. Thus, they saw the problem as so large and negative that it was potentially overwhelming, to avoid this they generally chose not to think about it. Earlier research into teaching about climate change focused on making sure people knew about the problem. However, more recently, research has found that knowing about climate change does not cause people to make environmentally friendly choices. This study helps to understand why this might be. The young people in this study knew about climate change but chose not to think about it. Their choice not to engage was logical: they did not see any solutions to the problem so ignored it to avoid distress. This suggests that when young people are taught about climate change this information needs to be carefully delivered so that they believe that there are solutions and that they can participate in these. This study also indicated that, to support a more positive view of the problem, young people’s education needs to be supported by wider societal changes.
This research would be beneficial to teachers tasked with delivering CCE. Firstly, this study demonstrated the importance of acknowledging the information about climate change that young people absorb outside of the classroom, particularly the negative way that this information is presented. Secondly, these findings suggest that young people currently feel low levels of agency to tackle the climate crisis, but that activities that allow them to participate in solutions would be potentially beneficial to building this. Finally, this study highlighted the importance of young people’s engagement in climate issues being supported by their wider culture. This is relevant to colleges and schools as a whole community as it suggests that CCE would be more effective if supported by the institution making visible moves towards sustainability. Moreover, young people suggested that deep investment in climate issues may not be socially acceptable. Through careful intervention schools could play an influential role in shifting these norms. However, this study also indicates that young people judge climate change to be an issue that requires government intervention. The negative perception of the future, which contributed to young people’s disengagement, was magnified by their perception that the government was not responding to the issue. Thus, these findings are also of political relevance as they suggest a relationship between government’s response to the climate crisis and young people’s ability to engage positively with the issue. Given that this has the potential to impact young people’s mental health in the present and their long-term attitude to the issue, this dimension of the findings cannot be ignored.